Platform Statement: Financial Stability

Ohio’s declining economy and changing labor needs are locking out those at the bottom of the economic ladder with the least finance options and/or skills.  Also the banking, foreclosure, and predatory lending crisis are having a significant negative effect in the low-to-moderate income (LMI) communities.  There should be an equitable and just distribution of funds/resources to assist those who need it.

Issue:  Financial Stability
Predatory lending practices and foreclosure policies have to be stopped.  For borrowers there is also a need to increase awareness and education about prudent borrowing practices and where they should seek recourse.  The problem has received attention from Congress and the change in political parties in Columbus should provide a more receptive consideration of regulation and remediation.  Financial institutions, corporations and businesses should be involved in framing the dialogue, information outreach and proposed actions to provide resources and offer products that will help persons/families in the low-to-moderate communities (LMI).

Issue:  Continuing Foreclosures and Severely Depressed Housing Market
The worsening foreclosure and late payment figures continue to grow as the country is on the edge of a recession or in one already.  The wave of foreclosures threatens to deepen the already depressed housing market (current projections based on adjustable rate mortgages trend increases throughout 2010).  The impact of unemployment on financial stability, the homes people are forced out of, the declining mortgage interest rates and buyer hesitancy due to job uncertainty all add to the cumulative affect of a depressed economy locally, across the state and nationally.  Keep or eliminate? (Tighter credit has thwarted would-be home buyers, aggravating problems in the housing market.  Many homeowners with adjustable rate mortgages are still facing steep monthly payment hikes.  Experts estimate some 2 million loans nationwide are due to reset at higher rates in the next 6 months.  Preliminary plans are underway between the City of Dayton and Montgomery County which will pool resources to assist persons facing foreclosure.

Issue:  PayDay Loan Offices are Increasing in the State of Ohio
Borrowers end up in a never-ending continuous cycle of owing their paychecks to the neighborhood payday lending store.  The payday loans are having a huge impact on the consumers' ability to make their payments and to live day-to-day, because they continually owe on their loans to the payday offices and with the increased amount of interest accruing each week.  Statewide the number of payday lending outlets exploded from 107 to 1996 to 1,554 in 2007.  The Coalition on Homelessness and Housing in Ohio successfully supported state legislation to address payday lending which capped the interest rate at 28 percent.  Annual rates now can reach as high as 391 percent.  Since the passage of PayDay loan legislation,  pay day businesses have discovered a loophole that allows them to charge higher interest rates for short-term loans (two week period or less).       

PRO CON

° Ohio reported one foreclosure filing for every 290 households.

° The state had 17,276 filings in November of 2007, up nearly 136% from October 2006.

° The State of Ohio was ranked 1st in the nation for foreclosures as of November 29, 2007.

° As of February 14, 2008, Dayton came in 15th nationwide for highest level of unemployment.

° Montgomery County had 5,076 filings in 2006, up 25.3% from 2005, and filings continue to climb each month.

° The delinquency rate for all mortgages nationwide climbed to 5.82% in the fourth quarter of 2007, the highest since 1985.

° More than 35,000 borrowers in the Miami Valley, including 17,015 in Montgomery County were found to be paying high fees to payday lenders in 2006.

° Montgomery County ranked fourth in the state in both loan fees and the number of "trapped borrowers" (those who took five or more high-interest payday loans a year).

° By 2006, payday loan offices had spread to all but two of Ohio's 88 counties. 35 of the counties have more than ten locations.

° The impact of a depressed economy and the foreclosure crisis continues to reduce the net worth of Ohio citizens.

° Predatory lending legislation was successfully enacted in the Columbus statehouse and nationwide.  Example: Dayton's anti-predatory lending ordinance adopted in 2001 was struck down in 2004 by the 2nd District Court of Appeals.


° American Financial Services has won lawsuits against municipal lending laws in several states.


° Continued loss of manufacturing jobs in Ohio, a transforming job market, and a change in the skills required to obtain a job (to more technology-based positions) are also possible causes of the eroding economy and decrease in the ability to replay mortgages and other debt.


° State budgets are strained by other priorities, such as education, the state penal system, health care issues, etc.


° State budgets are negatively impacted by the decline in revenue.


° Tendency to blame predatory lending, specifically for the current mortgage crisis, when other factors are also involved.


° Diminished access to credit and need for some limited sub-prime lending. Most access to sub-prime lending has disappeared due to the negative repercussions of the mortgage crisis.


Position:  Pro
 
Therefore, United Way of Greater Dayton Area will support efforts regarding financial stability legislation at the local, state and federal level, continue to advocate for the elimination of predatory lending practices and work to promote laws and policies that would assist persons to work their way out of foreclosure situations.  United Way should also advocate for ways to help stimulate the local economy move away from the current paralyzed market to positive financial activity.  All of these efforts should encompass our tri-county area.

Action: 
United Way should devote some staff and volunteer resources to this issue.  United Way volunteer leadership and staff will pursue opportunities to meet with elected officials, other funders and service providers to strategize about and advocate for increased financial stability.


Adopted by United Way of the Greater Dayton Area Board of Directors - 2008.  
Revised March 2009.
Open Your Heart
Lend Your Voice
Share Your Strength
Get Help